| Game Date | Home Team | Away Team | Score |
| 03/22/12 | Pirates | Dodgers | 6-2 |
|
|
| 03/22/12 | Mets | C of A | 8-8 |
|
|
| 03/22/12 | Reds | Cardinals | 9-8 |
|
|
| 03/29/12 | Cardinals | Mets | 4-16 |
|
|
| 03/29/12 | Pirates | C of A | 8-5 |
|
|
| 03/29/12 | Reds | Dodgers | 8-7 |
|
|
| 04/01/12 | Reds | Malibu | 10-13 |
|
|
| 04/01/12 | Dodgers | Cardinals | 4-5 |
|
|
| 04/01/12 | Mets | Pirates | 0-10 |
|
|
| 04/05/12 | Cardinals | Pirates | 11-13 |
| Cardinals: | Rimmon (39) | Pirates: | Noval (38) |
| Spitz (38) | | Loitman (26) |
| Geller (65) | | Kent (27) |
| | | Steinberg (55) |
|
| 04/05/12 | Dodgers | C of A | 3-9 |
| Dodgers: | Kramer (39) | C of A: | |
| Koo (38) | | |
| Gibbons (37) | | |
|
| 04/05/12 | Reds | Mets | 4-7 |
| Reds: | Kalt (34) | Mets: | Bergher (42) |
| Gatica (29) | | Kaye (32) |
| Teiger (35) | | Licht (25) |
| | | King (3) |
|
| 04/19/12 | Cardinals | Reds | 8-4 |
| Cardinals: | Rimmon (40) | Reds: | Gatica (37) |
| Rosten (29) | | Witmer (8) |
| Spitz (27) | | Kalt (42) |
| Abramov (19) | | White (12) |
|
| 04/19/12 | Dodgers | Pirates | 3-10 |
| Dodgers: | Gibbons (38) | Pirates: | McLarnon (38) |
| Koo (65) | | Steinberg (37) |
| Barnouw (3) | | Loitman (22) |
|
| 04/19/12 | Mets | C of A | 1-12 |
| Mets: | C. King (40) | C of A: | |
| Bergher (39) | | |
| Kaye (23) | | |
|
| 04/22/12 | Dodgers | Mets | 5-8 |
| Dodgers: | Gibbons (37) | Mets: | King (37) |
| Kramer (49) | | Bergher (39) |
| Gould (28) | | |
|
| 04/22/12 | Malibu | Cardinals | 13-3 |
| Malibu: | | Cardinals: | Geller (38) |
| | | Spitz (32) |
| | | Rimmon (38) |
|
| 04/22/12 | Reds | Pirates | 4-15 |
| Reds: | White (39) | Pirates: | Steinberg (31) |
| Gatica (39) | | Loitman (30) |
| Hanelin (30) | | McLarnon (11) |
| Teiger (14) | | |
|
| 04/29/12 | Pirates | Mets | 10-5 |
| Pirates: | McLarnon (32) | Mets: | King (39) |
| Dahan (30) | | Licht (35) |
| Steinberg (40) | | Drinkward-Hermann (40) |
| Kent (5) | | |
|
| 04/29/12 | Reds | Malibu | 10-15 |
| Reds: | White (39) | Malibu: | |
| Gatica (25) | | |
| Teiger (40) | | |
| Loscalzo (33) | | |
| Witmer (11) | | |
|
| 04/29/12 | Cardinals | Dodgers | 6-3 |
| Cardinals: | Rimmon (40) | Dodgers: | Gould (33) |
| Spitz (5) | | Koo (36) |
| Geller (40) | | Gibbons (40) |
| Abramov (26) | | |
|
| 05/03/12 | Mets | Reds | 7-2 |
| Mets: | King (37) | Reds: | Teiger (64) |
| Kaye (39) | | Loscalzo (38) |
| Licht (22) | | White (12) |
|
| 05/03/12 | Dodgers | C of A | 2-2 |
| Dodgers: | Gould (28) | C of A: | |
| Koo (60) | | |
| Barnouw (26) | | |
|
| 05/03/12 | Pirates | Cardinals | 7-3 |
| Pirates: | Z. Steinberg (38) | Cardinals: | Rimmon (36) |
| Noval (18) | | Rosten (25) |
| McLarnon (38) | | Geller (25) |
| S. Steinberg (3) | | |
|
| 05/06/12 | Pirates | Dodgers | 8-1 |
| Pirates: | Noval (31) | Dodgers: | Gould (38) |
| Steinberg (30) | | Barnouw (40) |
| McLarnon (22) | | Gibbons (38) |
|
| 05/06/12 | Malibu | Mets | 11-5 |
| Malibu: | | Mets: | King (37) |
| | | Bergher (40) |
| | | Drinkward-Herrmann (23) |
| | | Licht (20) |
|
| 05/06/12 | Reds | Cardinals | 6-3 |
| Reds: | White (87) | Cardinals: | Rimmon (55) |
| Gatica (16) | | Geller (23) |
|
| 05/10/12 | Mets | Dodgers | 8-5 |
| Mets: | C. King (34) | Dodgers: | Barnouw (40) |
| Kaye (33) | | Bauer (35) |
| Bergher (4) | | Koo (21) |
| | | Gibbons (12) |
|
| 05/10/12 | Pirates | Reds | 14-4 |
| Pirates: | McLarnon (36) | Reds: | Teiger (37) |
| Z. Steinberg (35) | | Loscalzo (31) |
| S. Steinberg (10) | | Witmer (26) |
|
| 05/10/12 | Cardinals | C of A | 11-11 |
| Cardinals: | Spitz (36) | C of A: | |
| Geller (33) | | |
| Abramov (40) | | |
| Rosten (26) | | |
| Coleman (16) | | |
|
| 05/13/12 | Cardinals | Mets | 7-5 |
| Cardinals: | Spitz (39) | Mets: | Bergher (40) |
| Geller (40) | | Licht (52) |
| Rimmon (40) | | |
| Coleman (18) | | |
|
| 05/13/12 | Reds | Dodgers | 10-9 |
| Reds: | Teiger (79) | Dodgers: | Barnouw (23) |
| White (25) | | Koo (39) |
| | | Bauer (25) |
| | | Gibbons (52) |
|